Course Proposals and CARMIn
Departments use CARMIn (the Course Approval, Remonstrance, Maintenance and Integration system) to electronically submit all proposals for new courses and course changes. To access this system, please contact June Hacker ( jhacker indiana.edu; 855-3953). For information regarding how to initiate or approve a course request, please see "Course Approval and Remonstrance (CARMIn)".
When a member of a department (faculty or staff) initiates a New Course or a Course Change document via CARMIn, the electronic document is automatically routed to the next person in the approval chain, who is either the Chair or the Director of Undergraduate Studies (DUS) of the department. The Chair or DUS can approve the request or return it—with comments—to the initiator. Once the Chair or DUS approves a request, it is then routed to the College. David Halloran, the Assistant Dean for Undergraduate Curriculum, and John Lucaites, the Associate Dean for Arts and Humanities and Undergraduate Education, review requests in consultation (if necessary) with appropriate members of the Committee for Undergraduate Education (CUE). Most course proposals can be approved at this stage. Proposals that raise significant questions of policy or pedagogy, however, may be brought before the full committee, which may ask the department to clarify their recommendations.
If approved by the College, course requests are required to be placed on a central university remonstrance list so that other units and campuses have an opportunity to review them. After the 30-day remonstrance period, they are routed to the Office of the Vice-Provost for Undergraduate Education for final approval (see “Remonstrance Procedure” below for detailed information).
Please remember the following when using CARMIn:
- Proposals for new courses and course changes should be examined and approved by the department (or program) before they are submitted to the College. Most departments have a faculty committee responsible for overseeing departmental curricular matters. The Chair’s or DUS’s approval of a course or curricular proposal is understood to signify a carefully considered departmental endorsement after faculty members in the department have had a chance to provide comments. Departments must discuss any issues of potential overlap or areas of concern with other departments and schools (and address these issues in their proposals) before sending a new course or course change proposal to the College.
- Departments should be careful when they modify courses that might be in use on other campuses. Any change to a course on the Bloomington campus will impact the entire IU system. The only exceptions to this rule are requests to discontinue a course and/or to modify course prerequisites because such requests are campus specific. Proposing a new course is sometimes less complicated than seeking significant revisions to a course already taught on multiple campuses. In order to ascertain which departmental course numbers are in use outside of IUB, run a query under the “Reports” link at http://ses.iu.edu/studentInfoSystems/sisServices/.
Please do not “recycle” course numbers. Using an “old” course number to refer to a new course creates duplication in the system-wide Course Catalog and is confusing for advisors and students. Before proposing a new course or course change, departments should discuss the specific revisions and potential overlaps with other units that may be affected. Finally, prior to submission, be sure to reserve a new number for the course by contacting University Student Services and Systems (formerly Student Enrollment Services); email: USSScrct@indiana.edu.
On the first workday of each month, a remonstrance list including all courses recently submitted to CARMIn will be distributed system-wide. Any faculty member or department with questions or concerns about a proposal on the list has a 30-day (strictly enforced) period to “remonstrate.” Reasons for filing a remonstrance include
- equivalence of a proposed course with a course already shared in the Course Catalog.
- confusion / overlap / redundancy with existing courses.
- failure to obtain required approvals.
- documented lack of resources or of faculty expertise to offer the proposed course.
Out of respect for their colleagues, faculty members have used this privilege only sparingly.
In the College, faculty and staff who have concerns about an undergraduate course or course change should direct all correspondence related to the filing and resolution of a remonstrance to John Lucaites ( asug indiana.edu), Associate Dean for Arts and Humanities and Undergraduate Education, and copy David Halloran ( whallora indiana.edu), Assistant Dean for Undergraduate Curriculum and June Hacker ( jhacker indiana.edu), Undergraduate Curriculum Coordinator. In this way, concerns are addressed by the appropriate people who will help ensure that the process is moving ahead expeditiously.
In the event that a remonstrance is filed, the two parties will correspond in a good-faith effort to address and resolve these issues. Until the remonstrance is withdrawn after the parties reach a satisfactory agreement, all changes are "frozen;” the process places the burden of proof on the proposer.
Please note the following:
- courses cannot be included in the College of Arts and Sciences Bulletin until they have gone through the remonstrance process.
- once a course has gone through the remonstrance process, it is entered into the IU system-wide Course Catalog and is available for adoption by any campus in the university system. Before a campus teaches a course for the first time, its use on that campus needs to clear remonstrance.
Applying for Special Course Designations
NOTE: College of Arts and Sciences Education (CASE)—Beginning in the summer of 2011 and thereafter, students new to IU Bloomington will be held to the new campus-wide General Education requirements. Since the structure and scope of these requirements closely resemble degree requirements in the College, our faculty adopted the new acronym "CASE" to designate courses that fulfill College-specific degree requirements for our majors. CASE will appear in this handbook and other official documents. The campus-wide General Education Curriculum has its own course review procedures. Information is available at http://gened.iub.edu/admin/GenEdCourseProposals.html.
Departments can request special College-specific designations (CASE Breadth of Inquiry credit, CASE Culture Studies credit, CASE Intensive Writing credit, and CASE Critical Approaches credit) for existing courses or for proposed courses. To do so, please fill out the relevant form or answer the appropriate questions at http://college.indiana.edu/faculty/uci/information.shtml. Requests for CASE special designations must be approved by the College. Always attach a copy of a syllabus when requesting special designations.
- Please do not list courses as carrying special designations in the Schedule of Classes, course descriptions, websites, blogs, or flyers until such approval has been granted.
Please bear in mind the following:
- only College of Arts and Sciences courses can be considered for any of these special College-specific (CASE) course designations.
- in some specific instances a course can carry more than one category of CASE designation (for example, EALC-E 251 Traditional East Asian Civilization carries CASE Social and Historical Studies credit and also CASE Culture Studies credit). However, a course cannot be classified in more than one CASE Breadth of Inquiry area (CASE A&H, CASE S&H, CASE N&M); see “CASE Breadth of Inquiry Credit” for a description of each area.
- students who sit in the same classroom and do the same work must receive the same credit. Since course numbers (such as EALC-E 251 in the last example) always carry the special designations that have been assigned to them, faculty and scheduling officers must be careful when joint-listing courses. Courses cannot be joint-listed if they carry incompatible designations (for example, if one course is designated CASE A&H and another course is designated CASE S&H). However, a course that does not carry any special designations can, with the prior approval of the Office of Undergraduate Academic Affairs, be joint-listed with a course that has special designations. To obtain approval, contact June Hacker ( jhacker indiana.edu) prior to scheduling.
- courses can never be joint-listed if one course is at the 100/200 level and the other course is at the 300/400 level.
- courses can never be joint-listed if one course carries campus-wide General Education credit and the other does not. (So far, these General Education approvals apply only to courses at the 100 and 200 level).
- College courses should not be joint-listed with a course or courses from other schools.
- scheduling officers should no longer add attributes or notes for any CASE designations other than Intensive Writing.